Education Chouinard Art Institute, Los Angeles 1956-1960 Solo Exhibitions 2000-01 Edward Ruscha, Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC. Traveling to: Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago; Miami Art Museum, FL; Modern Art Museum, Fort Worth, TX; Museum of Modern Art, Oxford, England.* 2000 Ed Ruscha: New Work, Anthony d'Offay Gallery, London Powders, Pressures and Other Drawings, John Berggruen Gallery, San Francisco* 1999 Ed Ruscha: Metro Plots, Gagosian Gallery, New York Edward Ruscha: Editions 1959-1999, Walker Art Center, Minneapolis, MN. Traveling to: Los Angeles County Museum of Art; University of South Florida Contemporary Art Museum, Tampa, FL. Edward Ruscha, Kukje Gallery, Seoul, South Korea* Ed Ruscha, Meta Gallery, Madrid, Spain 1998 Ed Ruscha's Light, The J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles Inventors, Boxers, Racecar Drivers, Artists, Etc., Marian Goodman Gallery, Paris, France Ed Ruscha, Anthony d'Offay Gallery, London, England Ed Ruscha: New Paintings, Gasgosian Gallery, Beverly Hills, CA 1997 Spaghetti Westerns, Milwaukee Art Museum, WI* Edward Ruscha, Jurgen Becker, Hamburg Germany Edward Ruscha: Cityscapes/O Books, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York* Miracle, Royal Academy of Arts film screening in association with Anthony d'Offay Gallery, London 1996 Ed Ruscha, Kantor Gallery, Los Angeles VOWELS: Paintings on Book Covers, Gagosian Gallery, Beverly Hills, CA 1995 New Editions, Remba Gallery, Los Angeles Anamorphic Paintings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Recent Drawings and Prints, Offshore Gallery, East Hampton, NY Sayings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York The End, Close Range Gallery, Denver Art Museum, CO 1994 Clockworks, Laura Carpenter Fine Art, Santa Fe, NM 1993 Edward Ruscha: Romance with Liquids, Gagosian Gallery, New York * Edward Ruscha: Standard Stations, Amarillo Art Center, Amarillo, TX * Edward Ruscha: New York, Space Gallery, Casino Knokke, Brussels, Belgium The Books of Ed Ruscha, Gund Hall, Harvard University Graduate School of Design, Cambridge, MA * 1992 Edward Ruscha: Stains, Robert Miller Gallery, New York * Edward Ruscha: New Paintings & Drawings, Galerie Thaddaeus Ropac, Salzburg, Austria * 1991 Ed Ruscha: Early Drawings, Modernism Gallery, San Francisco Ed Ruscha Paintings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Edward Ruscha, Galerie Carola Mosch Multiples and Editions, Berlin, Germany 1990 Ed Ruscha Prints, Richard Green Gallery, Santa Monica, CA Edward Ruscha, Galerie Trisorio, Naples, Italy Edward Ruscha, Thomas Segal Gallery and Barbara Krakow Gallery, Boston, MA Ed Ruscha: Prints from the 1960s & 1970s, Judith Goldberg Gallery Edward Ruscha, Galerie Ghislaine Hussenot, Paris, France Edward Ruscha: Obra Sobre Papel, Galeria Joan Prats, Barcelona, Spain Edward Ruscha: Obra Gravada, Galeria Joan Prats, Barcelona, Spain Edward Ruscha, Centre Cultural de la Fundacio la Caixa, Barcelona, Spain Edward Ruscha, Sheldon Memorial Art Gallery, University of Nebraska at Lincoln, NE * Ed Ruscha: New Paintings and Drawings, Karsten Schubert Ltd., London Edward Ruscha: Paintings and Drawings, The Texas Gallery, Houston, TX Ed Ruscha: Selected Portfolios, Castelli Graphics, Robert Miller Gallery, New York Edward Ruscha: Works on Paper, Galerie Bebert, Rotterdam, The Netherlands Los Angeles Apartments, Whitney Museum of American Art, New York* Ed Ruscha: Paintings, The Museum of Contemporary Art, Los Angeles 1989 Dreams and Other Works on Paper, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York New Paintings and Drawings, Tokyo Museum of Contemporary Art, Japan Ed Ruscha, Drawings and Prints, Thomas Babeor Gallery, La Jolla, CA Ed Ruscha: Selected Works of the 80s, James Corcoran Gallery, Santa Monica, CA Ed Ruscha: New Paintings and Works on Paper, Rhona Hoffman Gallery, Chicago, IL New Paintings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Ed Ruscha: Drawings, Michael Maloney Contemporary Art Inc., Santa Monica, CA Edward Ruscha, Musee National d'Art Moderne, Centre Georges Pompidou, Paris. Traveled to: Museum Boymans-van Beuningen, Rotterdam, The Netherlands; Fundacio Caixa de Pensions, Barcelona, Spain; Serpentine Gallery, London, England; Museum of Contemporary Art, Los Angeles. 1988 Edward Ruscha: Early Paintings, Tony Shafrazi Gallery, New York * Edward Ruscha: Recent Paintings, Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago Edward Ruscha: Recent Works on Paper, Karsten Schubert Ltd., London Prints, Gallery Takagi, Nagoya, Japan Drawing and Prints, Galerie Susan Wyss, Zurich, Switzerland Henry Vincent Gallery, Santa Diego, CA New Paintings and Drawings, Institute of Contemporary Art, Nagoya, Japan * New Drawings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Words Without Thoughts Never to Heaven Go, Lannan Museum, Lake Worth, FL. Traveled to: Williams College Museum of Art, Williamstown, MA * 1987 Edward Ruscha: Drawings, Acme Art, San Francisco Drawing Through the Years, Cirrus Gallery, Los Angeles Edward Ruscha: 35 Lunette Paintings Commissioned by Metro-Dade Art in Public Places Trust for Miami Dade Public Library, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York New Paintings, Robert Miller Gallery, New York The Works of Ed Ruscha, Contemporary Arts Museum, Houston, TX 1986 New Paintings, Fuller Goldeen Gallery, San Francisco Galerie Susan Wyss, Zurich, Switzerland Janie Beggs Fine Arts, Ltd., Aspen, CO New Paintings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Texas Gallery, Houston, TX 4 x 6: Zeichungen von Edward Ruscha, Westfalischer Kunstverein, Munster, Germany * 1985 Fischer Gallery, University of Southern California, Los Angeles Ed Ruscha: Quelques Dessins, Galerie Gilbert Brownstone, Paris, France New Paintings, James Corcoran Gallery, Los Angeles Octobre des Arts, Musee St. Pierre, Lyon, France Tanja Grunert, Cologne, Germany 1984 New Paintings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Recent Paintings and Works on Paper, Morgan Gallery, MO 1983 New Drawings, Bernard Jacobson Gallery, Los Angeles Ed Ruscha: Selection of Graphic Works 1970-1982, Cirrus Editions Ltd., Los Angeles Drawings, Galleria Del Cavallino, Venice, Italy Edward Ruscha: Drawings and Prints, Route 66, Philadelphia, PA 1982 Edward Ruscha: A Selection of Drawings from 1967 to 1972, John Berggruen Gallery, San Francisco Edward Ruscha: New Drawings, Castelli Uptown, New York Edward Ruscha: 1960-70, Castelli, Feigen, Corcoran, New York Prints, Jacobson/Hochman Gallery, New York New Paintings and Drawings, Flow Ace Gallery, Los Angeles, CA The Works of Ed Ruscha (Retrospective), San Francisco Museum of Modern Art. Traveled to: Whitney Museum of American Art, New York; Vancouver Art Gallery, Canada; San Antonio Museum of Art, TX; Los Angeles County Museum of Art. Steve's House of Fine Art, Los Angeles 1981 Ace Gallery, Vancouver, Canada Ed Ruscha: Drawings, Douglas Dean Courtenier, Inc., East Hampton, NY Castelli, Goodman, Solomon, East Hampton, NY Edward Ruscha: New Works, ARCO Center for Visual Arts, Los Angeles* Edward Ruscha: Drawings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York 1980 Edward Ruscha: Paintings, Ace Gallery, Venice, CA Edward Ruscha: Paintings and Drawings, Portland Center for the Visual Arts, OR Nigel Greenwood, Inc., London New Paintings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Ruscha: Selected Works 1966-1980, Foster Goldstrom Fine Arts, San Francisco 1979 Edward Ruscha: New Works, The Texas Gallery, Houston, TX heue Ausstellungen im InK, InK Halle fur Internationale neue Kunst, Zurich, Switzerland * Edward Ruscha: New Works, Marianne Deson Gallery, Chicago Ed Ruscha: New Works, Richard Hines Gallery, Seattle, WA 1978 A Selection of Paintings and Pastels 1974-1977, MTL Gallery, Brussels, Belgium Drawings and Prints, Castelli Uptown, New York Edward Ruscha: Books, Rudiger Schottle, Munich, Germany Edward Ruscha: Recent Paintings and Drawings, Ace Gallery, Vancouver, Canada Galerie Ricke, Cologne, Germany Graphic Works by Edward Ruscha, Auckland City Art Gallery, New Zealand* Peppers Art Gallery, University of Redlands, Los Angeles 1977 Recent Paintings, Ace Gallery, Venice, CA Edward Ruscha: Recent Drawings, Elmwood Arts Foundation and The Fort Worth Art Museum, TX Drawings by Joe Goode and Edward Ruscha, The Texas Gallery, Houston, TX Prints and Books, University of Lethbridge Art Gallery, Alberta, Canada 1976 Various Drawings, Ace Gallery, Vancouver, Canada Dootson/Calderhead Gallery, Seattle, WA Exhibitions and Presentations, Los Angeles Institute of Contemporary Art, CA Institute of Contemporary Art, London Paintings, Drawings, and Other Works by Ed Ruscha, Albright-Knox Art Gallery, Buffalo, NY* Sable Castelli Gallery Ltd., Toronto, Canada Edward Ruscha, Stedelijk Museum, Amsterdam, The Netherlands * Various Cheese Series, Gemini G.E.L., Los Angeles Wadsworth Atheneum, Matirx Gallery, Hartford, CT * 1975 Edward Ruscha/Drawings/Selected Prints, The Glasser Gallery, La Jolla, CA Edward Ruscha: Prints and Publications 1962-74, The Arts Council of Great Britain, traveled to twelve Arts Council Member Galleries; Northern Kentucky State University, Highland Heights, KY; Ace Gallery, CA.* Edward Ruscha: Prints, Northern Kentucky State University, Highland Heights, KY Miracle and Premium film screening, Fox Venice Theater, CA Paintings, Drawings and Film "Miracle", Galerie Ricke, Cologne, Germany Jared Sable Gallery Ltd., Toronto, Canada Leo Castelli, New York Books, Northlight Gallery, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ Tropical Fish Series, Gemini G.E.L., Los Angeles University of North Dakota Art Galleries, Grand Forks, ND Various Drawings, Ace Gallery, Los Angeles 1974 Works by Edward Ruscha, Francoise Lambert, Milan, Italy Contemporary Graphics Center, Santa Barbara Museum of Art, CA Edward Ruscha: Prints and Books, Root Art Center, Hamilton College, Clinton, NY * Golden West College, Huntington Beach, CA H. Peter Findlay Gallery, New York Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Recent Paintings, The Texas Gallery, Houston, TX 1973 Ace Gallery, Los Angeles Books by Ed Ruscha, UCSD Art Gallery, University of San Diego, CA Ed Ruscha: Drawings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Edward Ruscha: Graphics from the Collection of Donald Marron, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Edward Ruscha: Projection, Galerie Ursula Weavers, Cologne, Germany Stains/Edward Ruscha, Francoise Lambert, Milan, Italy The Greenberg Gallery, St. Louis, MO Edward Ruscha: Young Artist, John Berggruen Gallery, San Francisco Nigel Greenwood Inc., London Works by Edward Ruscha from the Collection of Paul J. Schupf '58, The Picker Gallery, Colgate University, Hamilton, NY * 1972 Corcoran & Corcoran Gallery, Coral Gables, FL Colored People, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York DM Gallery, London Ed Ruscha: Drawings, Leo Castelli Gallery, New York Ed Ruscha: Books and Prints, Mary Porter Sesnon Gallery, University of California, Santa Cruz* Janie C. Lee Gallery, Dallas, TX Minneapolis Institute of Arts, MN * 1971 Books, Nigel Greenwood Inc., London Drawings, Contract Graphics Associates, Houston, TX 1970 Alexander Iolas Gallery, New York * Books by Edward Ruscha, Galerie Heiner Friedrich, Munich, Germany * Edward Ruscha: Prints 1966-1970, Hansen Fuller Gallery, San Francisco Galerie Alexander Iolas, Paris, France 1969 Edward Ruscha: New Graphics, Multiples Inc., Los Angeles Irving Blum Gallery, Los Angeles La Jolla Museum of Art, CA 1968 Irving Blum Gallery, Los Angeles Galerie Rudolf Zwirner, Cologne, Germany 1967 Gunpowder Drawings, Alexander Iolas Gallery, New York 1965 Ferus Gallery, Los Angeles 1964 Ferus Gallery, Los Angeles 1963 Ferus Gallery, Los Angeles |
The Stable Gallery: In Conversation With Nicolas Carone
by Phong BuiAs part of the Rail’s ongoing effort to bring resources and historical awareness to the current dialogue in our ever-growing art community, I wrote an article several issues ago about The Club, and was able to interview Philip Pavia—the sculptor and organizer of The Club and publisher of It Is magazine. It was The Club that provided the informal yet critical format for panel discussions which included various topics: painting, sculpture, philosophy, music, anthropology and on some occasions even heated political debates. Now, with the recent addition of new gallery spaces beyond the Williamsburg area—Greenpoint, Dumbo and Bushwick—it would seem timely to follow up with the story of the legendary Stable Gallery.
The Stable Gallery began as a real horse stable on Central Park South, but it was more than just the first to convert an industrial space into an art gallery, a concept which anticipated fashionable Soho and the new Chelsea galleries. The Stable was also famous for having a broad and democratic philosophy. Besides the Stable Annuals, which involved the most established artists of the downtown scene at the time, it also showcased many young and emerging artists like Cy Twombly, Robert Rauschenberg and Joan Mitchell. In addition, it resurrected the eccentric and unique work of John Graham and Joseph Cornell.
The Stable Gallery was a perfect passageway for other galleries to come and pick their artists or to observe its unorthodox and experimental spirit. The following is an interview with the distinguished painter and teacher Nicolas Carone, who was the assistant director of the Stable Gallery’s first three or four crucial years. Carone was also a founding faculty member of the New York Studio School and the former director of the International School of Art in Umbria, Italy.
Phong Bui (Rail): In 1951, the members of The Club invited sixty-one artists to each submit one work for a big group show. It was called The Ninth Street Show. The appeal was that it included most, if not all, the artists of the downtown scene—the older and the younger generation. It must have been exciting to see the work of Kline, de Kooning or even Kewitin next to Fairfield Porter and Louise Bourgeois and Michael Loew. From what I’ve read and been told by some of the participants, it was a great success.
Nicolas Carone: Well, it was a success because it was more like a social event that anything else. Nobody was with a gallery in those days, especially the younger artists who were still trying to figure out what was going on, I mean in their own work. It was good for them to come to an event like that because they could meet the older artists, see what the older artists were doing.
Rail: Didn’t The Ninth Street Show consequently turn into the Stable Annual? Wasn’t that how the Stable Annual came to be?
Carone: I’ll get to that later, but first the story began with the Alexander Iolas who was running the Hugo Gallery at the time. I’m sure you remember the Blood Flame exhibit organized by Nicolas Calas and designed by Frederick Kiesler. Anyway, Iolas was a great friend of mine and given his background it made sense that someone like Eleanor Ward would be attracted to him. Iolas came from a mix Egyptian and Greek origins. He was very handsome and at one time a ballet dancer. He had a strong interest in esoteric philosophy. You can imagine the sophisticated European circles of Surrealist artists like Max Ernst, Yves Tanguy, Roberto Matta and many distinguished ex-patriots that were accessible to him. Even the formidable Donna Maria Ruspoli—she was a Princess—and the Marquis de Cuevas were helping Iolas with the gallery.
Rail: What about Eleanor Ward?
Carone: She was working for Christian Dior as a representative promoting The New Look. You know she primarily came from the fashion industry and had no experience in the art world. But she had this friend with a real horse stable building on 58th Street and 7th Avenue right by Central Park South. Since the friend had a long lease but was quitting her business—which was making mannequins, papier maché window displays for Saks Fifth Avenue, Bonwit Teller, all those fancy uptown stores—well, she was willing to give the space to Eleanor. The first thing Eleanor did was to put up a casual Christmas show with all kinds of Sunday painters and dilettantes. It was not serious at all but it got a lot of attention. It even got coverage in the New Yorker and many things were sold. Just to remind you, Eleanor gained the backing of a wealthy man because of that Christmas show… and that’s when she came to Iolas and asked his advice. He came to see the space and agreed to help her as a curator. Well, through his gallery, he put up a big group show that would officially introduce the Stable Gallery to the art world. The show included the obvious names of the modern Italian artists like de Chirico, Modigliani and Morandi—and it also made exceptions with some other work like Fazzini and de Pisis. My work was included in that show as well.
Rail: But with all of Iolas’ European connections, how did that have anything to do with the undercurrent scene downtown?
Carone: See, you have to understand in spite of his involvement with the Surrealists and even the Neo-Romantic artists like Pavel Tchelithew and Eugene Berman, he knew there was a new climate in the making. So, to his credit, having seen an enormous space like the Stable, he thought it would be a perfect opportunity to show some large abstract paintings.
Rail: You mean Abstract Expressionist paintings?
Carone: Not quite exactly. He had some notion about showing some young French painters like Matthieu, I suppose, as a way of prefacing what was to follow in New York. Anyway, things didn’t work out with Eleanor Ward, so Iolas terminated his relationship with her.
Rail: So when did you enter the picture and what was your role at the gallery?
Carone: Well, I met Eleanor through Iolas, I came in right after he left. The truth of the matter was she didn’t know what to do next. I tried to propose to her all different kinds of paintings that could be available for showing in the gallery. In fact, I showed he a big article about the Betty Parsons Gallery and the New Paintings in Vogue magazine, you know, with Barnett Newman, Jackson Pollock, Mark Rothko and Clifford Still. I said to her, “that’s the new painting, the new avant-garde.” She responded right away, “Yes, that’s what I want.” I told her, in that case, she would have to give me some time to find young artists qualified to have a show because most of them didn’t necessarily have enough work. They were still working things out. No one could make a statement overnight, anyway. You see, at that time, making a statement was paramount. That would have meant who you were. You could be the most talented guy in the world but if you didn’t make your statement you were out. That was one of the big reasons why most artists didn’t show their work until they were older. Don’t forget de Kooning did not have his first one-man show until 1948. I believe he was about 42 years old.
Rail: Yes, at the Charles Eagan Gallery. In any case, most of the older artists like de Kooning, Pollock, Rothko or Kline or Gorky were already with other established galleries. So you didn’t have much choice except to find good artists among the younger generation.
Carone: (laughs) That was my intention anyway. For instance, I came to visit a collector friend of mine’s apartment and I saw a big painting by Edward Dugmore that I liked. You know Dugmore and Ernie Briggs were from the West Coast where they had studied with Clifford Still. They came to New York at the height of everything that was happening. They were considered outsiders, but I didn’t care too much for all of that. I liked his work. So we gave him his first show at the Stable. That also gave me more time to look for other artists.
Rail: So it would appear to be good timing because from the Annual you could certainly pick and choose all kinds of artists and invite them to join your gallery.
Carone: Actually a friend that made it possible for me besides Philip Pavia and Conrad Marca-Relli at The Club was Jack Tworkow. He instigated the whole arrangement. I suggested to bring The Ninth Street Show to the Stable, Tworkow spoke to Pavia and some other artists, and they were all for it. That’s how the Annual came to be. But again that was just the Annual—otherwise most of my friends like Philip Guston, Marca-Relli, Vincente, they all wanted to join Charlie Eagen because of de Kooning. Guston finally got in. You must understand the whole climate then was about de Kooning. Critics like Tom Hess, Harold Rosenberg, they were busy building up de Kooning. De Kooning was the hot painter. Pollock was already in South Hampton drying out, so to speak. He already made his statement. He was seeing his psychiatrist and Lee was protecting him from everything going on.
Rail: I think the whole phenomenon of de Kooning versus Pollock simply rests on the fact that in de Kooning’s work, because he was trained academically and had more skill than Pollock, the visual vocabulary and the evolution of his process appears to be more cohesive. It’s really not a matter of judgment. I am just making a personal observation. What I mean is that de Kooning’s work is more tangible for emulation. After all, practically the whole second generation of young artists were painting under de Kooning’s influence, both abstractly and figuratively. In Pollock’s case it was different. Pollock’s influence didn’t really stop with Clement Greenberg and his circle of artist friends, such as Frankenthaler, Morris Louis or Larry Poons—even though part of its appeal for them was the decorative side of his late drip paintings. Pollock’s greater spiritual legacy continued right in to the Happenings with Allen Kaprow, also with Earth Art and Michael Heizer and with Robert Smithson. Anyway, what happened next?
Carone: I went to see a group show at the Samuel Kootz Gallery. I saw Cy Twombly’s paintings for the first time. They were painted mostly in black and white with enamel house paint. The surfaces were thickly painted but smooth at the same time. They looked like a combination of Franz Kline calligraphy and that wuality of Ryder’s—painterly and glowing. They had a real plastic sensibilities. Both Eleanor and I went to see him in his studio. A few days later, he came to see the space and liked the idea of the gallery and eventually agreed to show with us only if we would take on his friend Bob Rauschenberg as well. I liked Cy’s work and his discretion, so we put up a two-man show with his and Rauschenberg’s work together.
Rail: Cool. Didn’t you also mount a show of John Graham at the Stable? How did that happen?
Carone: Well, I had a very strong idea about the Stable. I didn’t want it to be just a gallery that only shows abstract paintings. I told Eleanor that we needed some figurative artists but whose work had to have a strong metaphysical basis. Of course, when I read Graham’s book System and Dialectics of Art, like everyone else at the time, I knew right away that this was a man who knew. He was a great connoisseur really. I asked among my friends but they didn’t know where he was. As every one of us knew, Graham was important to Gorky and de Kooning’s formative years in the late ’30s and early ’40s but the whole art world was different by the ’50s. Anyway, I knew a man named Don Braider who ran a local bookstore near my home in East Hampton. He was the one who told me where John Graham was in South Hampton. The strange thing was that, before Eleanor and I went to see him, I found out that Graham was married to Ilena Sonnabend’s mother. That means he was Leo Castelli’s father-in-law.
Rail: Yeah. That’s a really strange fact. Please go on.
Carone: You wouldn’t believe it. When we invited Graham to have a show at the Stable he came in to the gallery and he was thrilled. He even suggested a retrospective of his work. He said that he could arrange to get a lot of his work from the Philips Collection in DC. You would be surprised at the range of his work. Most people identify Graham’s work with his landmark cross-eyed women with all kinds of esoteric symbols and writing on their face or neck. I saw paintings that were like Barnett Newman’s, I mean long before Barnett became the painter as we know him. It wan an amazing and haunting exhibit. Every single painter in New York came to that show even though we didn’t manage to see one painting. In spite of all of that, some of my friends were against the idea that I was showing John Graham’s work. They had the same reaction when I showed Joseph Cornell earlier.
Rail: Was the Cornell show through Iolas’s connections?
Carone: Yes. I knew him through Iolas. Believe me, only a few supported me with this idea. Noguchi loved the Cornell show and because of that he later joined the gallery. And later Jack Tworkow and Joan Mitchell and even Myron Stout came in.
Rail: How would you compare the Stable with other galleries like Martha Jackson, Pointdexter, Tibor de Nagy…
Carone: Well, at the Stable Annuals many galleries would come and pick and choose their new artists. After three and a half years I had to quit my job because my own paintings demanded more time and I needed to have my own career as a painter. As a manner of fact I quit the Stable in order to show my work at George Stampfli’s gallery. It was alright with Eleanor. I left on friendly terms. She continued to consult with me later on so I still remained somewhat involved.
Rail: The Stable Annual came to an end in 1957.
Carone: It was unfortunate. Abstract Expressionism was nipped at the bud. It was forced out to make way for Pop Art. Yes, everything comes to an end.