Greece: The start of a systemic crisis of the Eurozone?

Paul De Grauwe
15 December 2009

Is the Greek crisis the beginning of a deeper sovereign debt crisis that could destabilise the Eurozone? This column argues the Eurozone is no closer to a debt crisis than the US, but some members are getting close. EU governments could bailout Greece and, to avoid having to do so, they should clarify their stance on the matter.

The Greek crisis has led to fears that this is only the beginning of a deeper sovereign debt crisis that could ultimately destabilise the Eurozone. Are these fears exaggerated? How to deal with these problems? These are some of the questions many observers have been asking themselves.
Origins of the present crisis

It is useful to start out with the origins of the present crisis. Figure 1 provides a useful way to organise our thoughts. It shows the average yearly changes (in percent of GDP) of private and public debt in the Eurozone.

The period 1999-2009 has been organised in periods of booms and busts: the boom years were 1999-2001 and 2005-07; the bust years were 2002-04 and 2008-09.

One observes a number of remarkable patterns.

* First, private debt increases much more than public debt throughout the whole period (compare the left hand axis with the right hand axis).
* Second, during boom years private debt increases spectacularly.

The latest boom period of 2005-07 stands out with yearly additions to private debt amounting on average to 35 percentage points of GDP.

* During these boom periods, public debt growth drops to 1 to 2 percentage points of GDP. The opposite occurs during bust years. Private debt growth slows down and public debt growth accelerates.

Again the last period of bust (2008-09) stands out. Public debt increases by 10 percentage points of GDP per year, mirroring the spectacular increase of private debt during the boom years (but note that the surge of public debt during the bust years of 2008-09 are dwarfed by the private debt surge during the preceding boom years).

Figure 1

Source: ECB, Quarterly Euro Area Accounts. Note: 2009 is until second quarter

The following picture emerges. During boom years the private sector adds a lot of debt. This was spectacularly so during the boom of 2005-07. Then the bust comes and the governments pick up the pieces. They do this in two ways.

* First, as the economy is driven into a recession, government revenues decline and social spending increases.
* Second as part of the private debt is implicitly guaranteed by the government (bank debt in particular) the government is forced to issue its own debt to rescue private institutions.

Thus the driving force of the cyclical behaviour of government debt is the boom and bust character of private debt. This feature is particularly pronounced during the last boom-bust cycle that led to unsustainable private debt growth forcing governments to add large amounts to its own debt.1
Is the public debt sustainable?

Financial markets now ask the question of whether the addition of government debt is sustainable. Clearly the rate of increase of the last two years is unsustainable. But with Eurozone government debt standing at 85% of GDP at the end of 2009, the Eurozone is miles away from a possible debt crisis.

Things are different in some individual countries, in Greece in particular, a country with a weak political system that has been adding government debt at a much higher rate than the rest of the Eurozone and that in addition has a debt level exceeding 100% of GDP. So, while the Eurozone as a whole is no closer to a debt crisis than is the US, some of its member states have been moving closer to such a crisis.

Is it conceivable that a debt crisis in one member country of the Eurozone triggers a more general crisis involving other Eurozone countries? My answer is that yes, it is conceivable, but that it can easily be avoided.2
A debt crisis is conceivable

Let’s start with the first part of the answer: It is conceivable. Financial markets are nervous and the most nervous actors in the financial markets are the rating agencies. One thing one can say about these institutions is that they systematically fail to see crises come. And after the crisis erupts, they systematically overreact thereby intensifying it.

This was the case two years ago when the rating agencies were completely caught off guard by the credit crisis. It was again the case during the last few weeks. Only after Dubai postponed the repayment of its bonds and we had all read about it in the FT, did the rating agencies realise there was a crisis and did they downgrade Dubai’s bonds.
Credit rating agencies playing catch-up

Having failed so miserably in forecasting a sovereign debt crisis, they went on a frantic search for possible other sovereign bond crises. They found Greece, and other Eurozone countries with high budget deficits, and started the process of downgrading. This in turn led to a significant increase in government bond rates in countries “visited” by the agencies.
Add to this that the ECB is still using the ratings produced by the same agencies to accept or refuse collateral presented by banks in the Eurozone, and one can see that all the elements are in place to transform a local crisis into a crisis for the system as a whole.
A systemic crisis can be avoided

It does not have to be that way, however. A systemic crisis can be avoided. Let’s start with Greece again. Although an outright default by the Greek government remains a remote possibility it is good to think through what the other Eurozone countries can and will do in that case. They can easily bail out Greece. It does not cost them that much. In the unlikely event that Greece defaults on the full amount of its outstanding debt, a bail-out by the other Eurozone governments would add about 3% to these governments’ debt – a small number compared to the amounts added to save the banks during the financial crisis.
A Eurozone bailout is likely

The other Eurozone governments are also very likely to bail out Greece out of pure self-interest. There are two reasons for this.

* First, a significant part of Greek bonds are held by financial institutions in Eurozone countries.

These institutions are likely to pressure their governments to come to their rescue.

* Second, and more importantly, a failure to bail out Greece would trigger contagious effects in sovereign bond markets of the Eurozone. Investors having lost a lot of money holding Greek bonds would likely dump government bonds of countries, like Spain, Ireland, Portugal, Belgium that they perceive to have similar budgetary problems.

The local sovereign debt crisis would trigger an avalanche of other sovereign debt crises. I conclude that the Eurozone governments are condemned to intervene and to rescue the government of a member country hit by a sovereign debt crisis.
Are bailouts illegal?

It is sometimes said that bail-outs in the Eurozone are illegal because the Treaty says so (see Wyplosz 2009 on this). But this is a misreading of the Treaty. The no-bail-out clause only says that the EU shall not be liable for the debt of governments, i.e. the governments of the Union cannot be forced to bail out a member state. But this does not exclude that the governments of the EU freely decide to provide financial assistance to one of the member states. In fact this is explicitly laid down in Article 100, section 2.3

Eurozone governments have the legal capacity to bail out other governments, and in my opinion they are very likely to do so in the Eurozone if the need arises.

Financial markets today do not seem to believe this conclusion. If they did, they would not price the risk of Greek government bonds 250 basis points higher than the risk of German government bonds. The scepticism of the financial markets has much to do with the poor communication by the EU-authorities that have given conflicting signals about their readiness to give financial support to Greece if a sovereign debt crisis were to erupt.

All this leads to the conclusion that the Eurozone governments should make clear where they stand on this issue. Not doing so implies that each time one member country gets into financial problems the future of the system is put into doubt.

Reinhart, C., and Rogoff, K., (2009), This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly, Princeton University Press, 496pp.
Eichengreen, B., (2007), The euro: love it or leave it?, VoxEU.org, 19 November.
Wyplosz, C., (2009), Bailouts: the next step up?, VoxEU.org, 21 February.

1 For a fascinating historic analysis of public and private debt see Reinhart and Rogoff(2009).
2 See also Eichengreen(2007) on this issue.
3 Here is the text: “Where a Member State is in difficulties or is seriously threatened with severe difficulties caused by natural disasters or exceptional occurrences beyond its control, the Council, acting by a qualified majority on a proposal from the Commission, may grant, under certain conditions, Community financial assistance to the Member State concerned”.

This article may be reproduced with appropriate attribution. See Copyright (below).

Topics: Europe's nations and regions

* eurozone
* Greece
* sovereign debt

Paul De Grauwe
Professor of international economics, University of Leuven, member of the Group of Economic Policy Analysis, advising the EU Commission President Manuel Barroso, and former member of the Belgian parliament.
Bookmark this: del.icio.us | Digg it | Tailrank | Reddit | Newsvine | Furl | Connotea | Technorati
Print this | Email this | Republish this | 9989 reads
Comments (2) | Login to post comments
Are bailouts illegal?
On January 5th, 2010 T. Saarenheimo says:

In quoting the Treaty's no-bailout clause, Professor de Grauwe omits a critical piece. The Treaty says that the Community or a member state "shall not be liable or assume the commitments" of any EU government body [Art 103 of the Nice Treaty, emphasis added]. Hence, not only can member states not be forced to bail out another member state, they are not allowed to do so, except when acting jointy under the exception of Art 100. Even then, getting a qualified majority in the Council in favour of the required interpretation that Greece's fiscal difficulties are due to "natural disasters or exceptional occurrences beyond its control" constitutes no small legal/political hurdle.

* Login or register to post comments

A dissenting view
On December 19th, 2009 mario.nuti says:

For an alternative view, looking at European bail-outs as unaffordable, probably illegal, and necessarily highly conditional, see http://dmarionuti.blogspot.com/2009/12/european-bail-outs-unaffordable-i..., with an exchange of comments with Paul de Grauwe.
D. Mario Nuti
Blog "Transition" http://dmarionuti.blogspot.com/

* Login or register to post comments


22 σχόλια:

Ανώνυμος είπε...

If you are going for finest contents like myself, only pay a visit
this web site every day since it presents quality contents, thanks

My web-site ... what is garcinia cambogia

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Everyone loves it when folks come together and share ideas.
Great blog, keep it up!

my blog making money online from home

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Please let me know if you're looking for a writer for your site. You have some really great articles and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I'd absolutely
love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine.
Please shoot me an e-mail if interested. Regards!

my blog post; pure garcinia cambogia reviews

Ανώνυμος είπε...

May I just say what a comfort to discover someone that really knows what
they're discussing on the internet. You certainly know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people have to look at this and understand this side of the story. I was surprised that you're not more popular given
that you certainly have the gift.

Feel free to surf to my web-site :: Zinn collection

Ανώνυμος είπε...

If some one desires expert view on the topic of blogging then i propose him/her to go to see
this website, Keep up the nice job.

my blog post ... Buy Androsolve

Ανώνυμος είπε...

I am sure this post has touched all the internet users, its really really pleasant piece of writing on building up new web site.

Also visit my web-site; Ultra SLim Patch Review

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Hey there would you mind stating which blog platform you're using? I'm looking
to start my own blog soon but I'm having a tough time deciding between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design and style seems different then most blogs and I'm looking for something unique.
P.S My apologies for being off-topic but I had to ask!

my page Muscle building supplement

Ανώνυμος είπε...

It's great that you are getting ideas from this article as well as from our dialogue made at this place.

My blog post ... Best Male Enhancement

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Hey there this is kinda of off topic but I was wondering if blogs use WYSIWYG editors
or if you have to manually code with HTML. I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding expertise so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated!

Also visit my blog: Pure HCA

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed!
Extremely useful information particularly the last part :) I care for such info
a lot. I was seeking this certain information for a very long time.
Thank you and good luck.

Here is my web page :: Best Wrinkle Cream

Ανώνυμος είπε...

you're truly a excellent webmaster. The web site loading speed is amazing. It kind of feels that you are doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterwork. you've performed a great job
on this topic!

Feel free to visit my website: Liposom

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Hello mates, how is all, and what you desire to say concerning this post, in my view its really awesome in
favor of me.

my web-site Diet Patch Weight Loss

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all people you really recognise what you're speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Please additionally talk over with my website =). We can have a hyperlink alternate agreement among us

Feel free to surf to my blog post :: Revitalize

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Pretty! This was an incredibly wonderful article. Many thanks for supplying this info.

Also visit my blog Rejuvenex reviews

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
The text in your content seem to be running off the screen
in Safari. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know.
The design and style look great though! Hope you get the problem fixed soon.

Also visit my weblog :: Fast Muscle Growth

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Hi to all, how is the whole thing, I think every one is getting more from this
website, and your views are pleasant in favor
of new visitors.

My webpage :: the Diet Patch

Ανώνυμος είπε...

I am not sure where you are getting your info,
but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or
understanding more. Thanks for excellent info I was looking for this info for my

Feel free to visit my page Home Staging Business

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Your way of describing all in this paragraph is in fact nice, all be capable of without difficulty be aware of it, Thanks a lot.

my web site: Green coffee diet ()

Ανώνυμος είπε...

I'm curious to find out what blog platform you have been working with? I'm experiencing some small security
problems with my latest blog and I'd like to find something more risk-free. Do you have any solutions?

Max Thermo Burn Muscle

Ανώνυμος είπε...

I want to to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every bit of it.
I have got you book-marked to look at new things you post…

My weblog: Buy VImax

Ανώνυμος είπε...

I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This article posted at this site is in fact nice.

My page - home income profit system

Ανώνυμος είπε...

Hi, i think that i noticed you visited my web site so i came
to return the favor?.I'm trying to to find things to enhance my site!I guess its good enough to make use of a few of your concepts!!

Here is my homepage - Automated pay day